Does Information Lie Beneath Reality?
How can resetting a memory produce heat? Forgetting seems like an absence, not an action. Yet a small experiment reveals a physical cost.
In 2012, Antoine Bérut and his colleagues reported an experiment in Nature. They trapped a tiny glass bead with laser light. The bead could occupy either of two positions, representing zero and one. To erase the memory, the researchers drove it toward one chosen position, regardless of its starting point. As they slowed the operation, the average heat release approached the minimum that physicist Rolf Landauer had predicted. (cpt.univ-mrs.fr)
Nothing vanished into a mysterious realm of numbers. The team moved a physical object through a controlled process. Nevertheless, the result invites a larger question: if information processing obeys physical laws, could informational relationships help explain where physical reality comes from?
We must climb carefully from that laboratory question toward the universe. Each step demands a different kind of evidence.
What a Bit Actually Tells Us
Before we call the universe information, we need to decide what that word means.
In everyday speech, information often means useful knowledge. A weather warning carries information because it tells us whether to bring an umbrella. However, information theory asks a narrower question: which alternatives could occur, and how much uncertainty does a result remove?
Claude Shannon developed this mathematical approach in his 1948 paper, “A Mathematical Theory of Communication.” He separated the engineering problem of transmitting messages from their meaning. Learning the outcome of a fair coin toss removes one bit of uncertainty. Either outcome has the same chance. By contrast, learning an almost certain outcome removes less uncertainty. (home.csulb.edu)
Imagine two envelopes. One contains a familiar sentence. The other contains a meaningless sequence of letters. You might value the sentence more, but meaning alone does not determine how much information a communication system must handle. Shannon’s framework concerns possible messages and their probabilities, not their wisdom. (home.csulb.edu)
The bead experiment gives this abstract idea a physical setting. Resetting turns two possible starting states into one standard ending state. The final memory no longer distinguishes those starting points. For an ideal reset of an equally likely classical bit in a thermal environment, Landauer’s bound specifies a minimum average heat cost. It does not assign an identical heat release to every individual attempt. (cpt.univ-mrs.fr)
Nor should we equate that controlled operation with clicking “delete” on an ordinary file. The experiment addresses a particular physical reset, not every action that software calls deletion. (cpt.univ-mrs.fr)
The distinction matters beyond vocabulary. When we ask how efficiently a machine could work, we need to separate a fundamental physical limit from the choices of its designers. A better design might remove waste. It could not simply negotiate away a genuine law of nature.
Still, a limit on handling information does not establish that information supplies the substance of everything. A rule about bookkeeping does not, by itself, explain what fills the warehouse.
Could Relationships Give Rise to Space?
Now turn the question around. Instead of asking how matter carries information, ask whether deeper relationships could give rise to the matter and space we recognize.
Physicist Tadashi Takayanagi explores this possibility in his 2025 research essay, “Emergent Holographic Spacetime from Quantum Information,” in Physical Review Letters. Holography connects certain theories with gravity to quantum theories without gravity in fewer dimensions. The two descriptions offer different mathematical accounts of corresponding physics. (journals.aps.org)
A useful comparison might involve two languages describing the same event. Neither language necessarily creates the event. Yet one description might reveal a relationship that the other hides. This comparison concerns descriptions only. It does not capture the mathematics that makes holography powerful.
One important connection involves entanglement. Quantum systems can share a joint state that no collection of separate states fully captures. Within particular holographic settings, physicists relate a measure of this entanglement to the area of a surface in the corresponding gravitational geometry. Such results suggest that patterns of quantum relationships could help account for spacetime itself. (journals.aps.org)
The possibility reverses an intuitive picture. Rather than imagining objects first and relationships second, we can ask whether relationships come first. Perhaps the deeper account would explain why notions such as distance make sense at all.
However, a suggestive reversal cannot substitute for a complete theory. Takayanagi identifies major open problems, including extensions to realistic cosmologies. His essay develops a theoretical research direction. It does not report an experiment establishing an informational foundation for our universe. (journals.aps.org)
We therefore need three distinct levels of confidence. The bead experiment tests the thermodynamics of erasure. Holographic research develops mathematical connections between quantum information and geometry. The claim that information constitutes ultimate reality adds an interpretation beyond either achievement. Neither source establishes a cosmic digital program or an outside programmer. (cpt.univ-mrs.fr)
What observation could distinguish an informational foundation from an equally successful description of ordinary physical reality?
A convincing proposal should answer that question. It might predict a measurable result that a rival account does not. Alternatively, both accounts might predict exactly the same observations. In that case, their disagreement would concern interpretation rather than an experimental difference.
This demand does not diminish the ambition. It gives the ambition a target.
When the Pattern Becomes a Person
Before following the idea toward human identity, we should hear its strongest objection.
In his 2025 essay, “The Universe Is Not Made of Information,” physicist Gregg Jaeger argues that information depends on physical objects and the ways we encode their properties. A detector’s click can represent a result. So can a mark on paper. Neither example shows that information creates the object that carries it. Jaeger therefore challenges the leap from information’s usefulness to its supposed role as reality’s foundation. His essay offers a critical argument, not an experimental verdict. (open.bu.edu)
Consider a musical score. Its arrangement tells a musician what to play, but the notation does not explain why instruments or sound exist. The analogy has limits, since physical information need not resemble written instructions. Nevertheless, it exposes the central question: have we explained existence, or have we developed a remarkable description of it?
A proponent could reply that fundamental information means objective relationships, not messages awaiting a reader. That reply sharpens the debate. It also leaves work to do. The proposal must specify those relationships, explain their physical consequences, and show what the word “information” contributes.
Now imagine a much more personal case.
Suppose a future technology could record every physical detail necessary to reproduce a human being. Suppose it could then construct someone with the same memories, habits, fears, and hopes. These assumptions define a thought experiment. They do not follow from holography or the heat cost of erasure.
Would the reconstruction continue your life, or begin another life with your memories?
Imagine that the original person survived. Both people might recognize the same childhood home. Each might remember making the same promise. Yet they would stand in different places and soon gather different experiences. Which one would inherit your obligations? Would either possess a stronger claim to your name?
The puzzle becomes even harder if the original no longer exists. Matching memories might convince everyone else. They might even convince the reconstruction. But would matching a description guarantee continuity of experience?
We should not hide that question inside the word “copy.”
The ethical questions would also demand attention. If someone could reconstruct a mind, who should control its records? Would permission to store those records include permission to create a person from them? Could anyone claim ownership over the resulting individual?
Likewise, if future systems could suffer, their creators would face responsibilities that no storage specification could settle. Creating such a system for a brief task might create more than a useful tool. Erasing it might involve more than reclaiming memory. These conditional questions concern moral judgment, not consequences that current physics has established.
Return, finally, to the bead. Its reset offers a modest but profound lesson: physical operations carry physical consequences. It does not tell us whether information underlies existence, or whether a perfect reconstruction would preserve a person.
Future research may uncover deeper connections between relationships and reality. As it does, we should keep asking two questions together: what does the evidence explain, and what have we merely renamed?
Expand Your Tech Knowledge
Dive deeper into the world of Cryptocurrency and its impact on global finance.
Discover archived knowledge and digital history on the Internet Archive.
OPEDV1